Free Agency: Week 1 Analysis.
Hello friends and family of the Wilderness. While this year's Free Agent Frenzy could hardly be called a frenzy so far this year, it doesn't mean significant changes haven't been made by teams this year. We can look at what the Wild have done so far and smile and salivate at the thought of finally making a comeback to the playoffs, but what about the other teams standing in our way? I've taken the liberty of analysing a couple of the changes our good ‘'friends'' in the Northwest division have made, since they're the ones the Wild share nearly 30% of the regular season with. What I've done is enumerate all of the free agent signings as well as all the re-signings, because they were technically free agents. So don't tell me ‘'they already had that guy'', I know! I've also listed the departures from each team, their salary cap status and my thoughts. I thought Bryan and Nathan would jump in, but it turns out they were busy, so I'm flying solo this time around, but it may be just as well, because this analysis turned out to be pretty lengthy.
(Salary cap info from capgeek.com)
Make the jump and prepare to study our opposition.
Additions/Signings : Guillaume Latendresse, Brad Staubitz, Eric Nystrom, Matt Cullen, Warren Peters, Drew Bagnall, Matt Kassian, Nate Prosser, James Sheppard, Jarod Palmer, Jon DiSalvatore, Jamie Fraser, Dennis Endras, Robbie Earl
Departures : Derek Boogaard, John Scott, Andrew Ebbett, Jamie Sifers
Cap situation: Payroll: 56,846,028
Bonuses: 975,000
Cap space: 3,528,972
Roster spots filled : 23 (Which is the max: 20 dressed, 3 scratched. We have the most spots filled in the league!)
Thoughts
The Wild have certainly become a better team, regardless of what anyone who wanted Boogey re-signed says. For one thing, they got rid of Boogs and Scott, two fighters, not hockey players. In their stead, we've got Brad Staubitz and Eric Nystrom, two hockey players who can certainly hold their own in a fight, play with energy and *gasp* can actually score more than 0 goals in a season (Sorry Boogs, please don't find me and punch my face off!). I will give credit where credit is due though, the both of them were fun to watch destroy their hapless competitors and they almost matched James Sheppard's production this season.
They've also re-signed last season's surprising hero Guillaume Latendresse to a 2 year deal worth 5 million, and if he continues in his 25-goal-in-55-games pace, he will be a hell of a bargain! I have no doubt that with the signing of Matt Cullen, our first bona-fide 2nd line center in a while (don't let the fact he never broke 50 points fool you, he's a 2nd line center.) Martin Havlat will return to his natural form and Guillaume Latendresse will continue to rip it up for us.
Andrew Ebbett signed with Ed Jovanovski and the Phoenix Coyotes interestingly enough. It's too bad, because he's got potential, but I guess he didn't fit into CF's plans anymore.
We've still got some cap space left, but no more roster spots to fill (Which I find strange, since we don't officially have a back-up goaltender signed just yet), meaning the most reasonable course of action would be trades, but it seems CF has either had some troubles selling the very little assets we have, or the right deal hasn't come along yet.
I love how thehockeynews.com considers the Wild to be one of the three losers in the Free Agent Frenzy, when we made our team considerably better than it was by letting dead weight go and getting a top six forward. Calgary of course, wasn't one of those three losers, because well.... you figure it out! The columnist doesn't even really explain why the Wild did badly enough that they were one of three teams to be considered losers. I just don't get it. They don't see it from a Wild fan perspective I guess...
What still needs to be done? Well, re-signing Hards should be a top priority, and maybe trying to get a scorer for Mikko Koivu and a 6th d-man for insurance. If Pierre-Marc Bouchard comes back, the scorer may not be as needed, although it would be interesting to see a *Scorer*-Koivu-PMB line, but it would be very unlikely and very costly, as in probably Brent Burns + prospects.
Our latest signing of goalie Dennis Endras gives us even more depth at a position we're already strong in, and gives us some more trade options, plus if we do trade away a goalie, we'll still have a good starter, a good back-up, and 2 good goalies in Houston, which is fine by me. In fact, this signing could very well mean the departure of a goalie in the near future.
Our prospect pool just got MUCH better with the additions of Casey Wellman, Nate Prosser, Jarod Palmer, Mikael Granlund and Dennis Endras. We've got very solid depth at D, we've gotten better at center and forward as a whole, and we've got some good up and coming goaltending in Matt Hackett and Anton Khudobin (assuming he re-signs), to go along with Niklas Backstrom and Josh Harding, a very good tandem.
Wild fans, we're on the right track. Brace yourselves for the playoffs.
Additions/Signings : Keith Ballard, Victor Oreskovich, Dan Hamhuis, Joel Perrault, Manny Malhotra, Jeff Tambellini, Alexandre Bolduc, Aaron Rome
Departures : Andrew Raycroft, Steve Bernier, Michael Grabner, Nathan McIver
Cap situation: Payroll: 58,033,333
Bonuses: None
Cap space: 1,366,667
Roster spots filled : 22
Thoughts:
Ahhh the Nucks... They undoubtedly became better since the end of the playoffs, but not by that much. I believe Hamhuis is overrated and overpaid. I expect that signing to bite them in the ass a la Jay Bouwmeester. Manny Malhotra was grossly overpaid as well. They also acquired the goalie whacker, Keith Ballard, whom I don't think will be much of an improvement to their squad. Sure he's got his moments, but nothing special IMO (I probably just pissed off a whole lot of people here, sorry!).
Andrew Raycroft is gone, meaning either they want a less expensive option, or they're bringing up Cory Schneider, which just may end up stunting his development more than anything, because Bobby Lou's clearly the top dog in the V (although you never know)
A Bieksa for Filatov rumor has been floating around, which could be bad news for us, because if you remember well, in his short time in the NHL, he scored a hat-trick against the Wild.
They've added a couple of depth players in Joel Perrault and Jeff Tambellini (son of Oilers GM Steve interestingly enough!)
All in all, the Nucks don't have too much cap space left, but they could end up moving some players to make way for Cody Hodgson and Jordan Schroeder, and when all's said and done, the Nucks may give us a pretty hard time this season. They're one of the most improved team in the Northwest Division. Look for them to get maybe a back-up goalie for Roberto Luongo so that they can keep Schneider in the minors and maybe get some more depth at forward as they now have a very well-balanced defense.
Additions/Signings : Alex Tanguay, Olli Jokinen, Tim Jackman, Raitis Ivanans, Henrik Karlsson, Logan MacMillan, Cam Cunning, Henrik Karlsson, Ryan Stone
Departures : Eric Nystrom, Chris Higgins, Jason Jaffray, David Van Der Gulik
Cap situation: Payroll: 58,250,000
Bonuses: None
Cap space: 1,150,000
Roster spots filled : 21
Thoughts:
Good Lord did this team plummet quickly! Trading Dion Phaneuf, re-acquiring Jokinen, getting Ales Kotalik and Chris Higgins (the latter is gone, Kotalik likely gone too), and they're getting rather old too. Sutter's head may be on a stake right now, but you can't say he isn't trying.
He re-invited Alex Tanguay and Olli Jokinen for another round in CGY, which made many eyebrows go crazy and a lot of drinks spit out by Flames fans. While I do think Sutter's reasoning for bringing back Jokinen is utter idiocy, it's not as bad a move as everyone thinks. Let me explain: In his first stint with the Flames, Jokinen cost 5.5 million to underachieve rather badly. This time around, he costs 3 million, which is much more reasonable for a guy who had 50 points. While he's far from the form of his Florida days, the move shouldn't be dismissed so quickly, although I think we should all understand Flames fans, because after all, Shep's been re-signed!
Other than that, I think Tanguay's not too bad of an acquisition in itself; not too expensive, played not too bad hockey in CGY, but the thing is, they're planning to make an Iginla-Jokinen-Tanguay line as their top line, which to me looks kind of iffy. But then again, who are we to talk?
Fan favourite Nystrom is now on our side, and they seemingly replaced him with Raitis Ivanans, who is a feared fighter, but not much else. They might as well have signed Boogaard. That being said, Ivanans will bring order and fear on the ice during his few minutes of play.
Barring major changes, which are unlikely to improve the team too much since they're close to the cap maximum, look (and hope) for the Flames to flame out once again this year. They would need some youthful players to take over on forward in the near future. They still have a pretty good defensive corps and one of the best goalies in the business in Miikka Kiprusoff, but this squad could be among the oldest this year.
Additions/Signings : Taylor Hall, Colin Fraser, Steve MacIntyre, Jason Strudwick, Alexandre Giroux, Jim Vandermeer, Martin Marincin, Kurtis Foster, Richard Petiot, Brad Moran
Departures : Riley Nash, Denis Grebeshkov, Patrick O'Sullivan, Chris Minard, Ryan Stone, Ethan Moreau
Cap situation: Payroll: 48,646,167
Bonuses: 3,977,500
Cap space: 14,731,333
Roster spots filled : 20
Thoughts:
Here's a team that's being completely Over-Halled (see what I did there? Hahaha) Drafting Taylor Hall will certainly have an immediate impact and help them VERY much. They're also expected to buy out Robert Nilsson, and they've already shed Ethan Moreau, Denis Grebeshkov and Patrick O'Sullivan, as well as putting Sheldon Souray on waivers. All this can be called shaking things up.
They've acquired Kurtis Foster. It will not be fun to have to see him in an Oilers jersey that often, not only because of sentimental reasons, but because he's coming off a career year in which he finally proved he's a good player in this league.
They've also made quite a few depth improving moves, which will help because Lord knows they've got a habit of playing lots of different players during the course of a season.
All of their shedding has given the Oilers lots of cap space to play with, but they're likely going to play it conservative this time around to not put themselves in the pickle they were in this year again. That, and they still need to re-sign some key RFAs in the likes of Sam Gagner, Andrew Cogliano and maybe Gilbert Brule and Devan Dubynk.
They should also look to try and get rid of the Bulin Wall and get a new #1, because JDD isn't ready yet. The Oilers won't be in the cellar of the NHL this year, but I would be surprised to see them make the playoffs because they still have a ways to go.
Additions/Signings : Daniel Winnik, Julian Talbot, Kyle Quincey, John Grahame, Greg Mauldin, David Liffiton, Jason Bacashihua, Kevin Porter, Raymond Macias, Philippe Dupuis, David Van der Gulik, Brandon Yip,
Departures : T.J Hensick, Brett Clark, Tom Pressing (Maybe, Mile High Hockey says his contract has been bought out and according to capgeek, it's all but official), Brian Fahey
Cap situation: Payroll: 37,686,667
Bonuses: 2,787,500
Cap space: 24,500,833
Roster spots filled : 19
Thoughts
JS: They haven't made much of a splash yet in FA, but they've made a boatload of minor league and depth signings. Their key acquisition so far is Daniel Winnik, so... yeah... you know what I mean. They do have three important-ish departures in T.J. Hensick, Brett Clark and reportedly Tom Pressing, whose alleged buyout puzzles many Avs fans.
We've fared pretty good against the Avs this year, but they're going to be even more dangerous as guys like Matt Duchesne, Ryan O'Reilly and Peter Mueller (assuming he re-signs; he's a RFA) continue to grow.
Looking at their depth chart, I'm seeing a massive minus on defense. It's certainly something they should look to improve over the summer and they have more than enough cap space to do so right now. Another big question mark is Marek Svatos for two reasons: A) He had an absolutely horrible year, scoring only 11 points in 54 games (rather close to James Sheppard territory... in fact, since Svatos has posted better numbers than Shep over the years, I feel he might've had exactly as bad a season as Shep) and B) He's an unrestricred free agent. There's no doubt the guy's a good player, but right now, he's not in the Avs depth chart so they will be looking to either re-sign him, which could be surprising, or finding a replacement for him, perhaps on the second line. While there aren't too many options in the FA pool, I believe they could easily trade to get the spot filled.
It's clear the Avs won't be staying pat for long. They, as well as many other GMs around the league, are waiting on how things play out for the next few days. Clearly the signing of Kovalchuk will spawn a lot of movement since it would put whoever he signs with (likely Devils, but maybe Kings) in an obligation to move some salary.
It would be hard to imagine them not making the playoffs this year, but it may depend on their off-season moves and a quick start like they had last season.
Overall, I believe the Oilers are the most improved team, followed by the Canucks, then the Wild, the Flames and finally the Avs.
The Oilers shed a lot of cap space, drafted Taylor Hall, got rid of many underachievers (with a bit of luck and shrewd moves).
Then the Canucks, for the obvious reason that they got 2 top-4 d-men and a great 3rd-4th liner, albeit they overpaid for all of them.
The Wild finally got a 2nd line center, got rid of our hockey-impaired players to get some real 4th liners and got some tantalizing college talent on our side. Some will say that Cullen got overpaid, mostly because they compare him with Matthew Lombardi, who got the exact same deal. I would only half agree with this. I believe we signed the better of the two. Sure Lombardi is quick and young, but he isn't nearly as well balanced as Cullen. What's more, Cullen is ecstatic to be home in Minny (or so I've read). 3.5 million a year may be rather high, but that's the reality of the FA market: EVERYONE gets overpaid. I also can't wait to see Wellman and Palmer, two of the most wanted college UFAs of 2010, as well as Prosser. I believe CF struck gold with these guys.
4th on the improvement chart would be the Flames because even though they made some questionable acquisitions, they made more of them than the Avs. Plus, Jokinen DID have 50 points this year, which is more than we can say about guys like Winnik
The Avs are last for now because they haven't done much at all, but that's likely to change during the course of this week.
Other things I have noticed:
- - No team has had a very significant departure so far. And no, Boogaard doesn't count as a significant departure, let it go!
- - How the hell did Edmonton give away nearly 4M in bonus money? Do they have a losing bonus or something? Seriously though, they're the fifth highest team in terms of bonus money given and well, I don't really understand how that works...
- - Matt Cullen has a limited NTC... I probably missed this while I was moving (I missed out on all the fun!)
- - Nhl.com doesn't have the best free agent tracker. By far.
Hope this gives you an idea of what we'll be up against come October, I'll have another update for you next week, and every following week until the end of the free agency period!
29 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
Well done, JS. Very thorough, very well thought out. Sorry I did not get in on it.
I think the Wild have gotten better, though I have strong doubts about their ability to keep up with the top teams. Vancouver solidified it’s defense, coupled with scoring, they could be dangerous. Calgary is going to be a mess this year, and Edmonton is still dismantling for the rebuild. Colorado, while quiet, had a damn fine team last year. However, if they continue to rely on Anderson to stop 60 shots a game, it could be a long year for them.
Hockey Wilderness
Assistant Editor:SBN Minnesota
Rule #17: You may not impersonate representatives of Hockey Wilderness and handout NHL themed wrist bands.
Agreed
Colorado relying too much on Anderson is another reason they’ll need to look into improving their D.
The main reason I say EDM improved so much is because they’ve liberated some dead weight without needing buyouts (except maybe Nilsson). This will give them more breathing room and money to spend on their RFAs.
Looking forward to see the other moves that are sure to happen later this summer once all the important FAs are signed (or un-signed).
JS, Champion of the first ever Hockey Wilderness Playoff Bracket Challenge! WHOOOOOOOO!
twitter: BubbleWild48
One point of contention...
Nystrom actually scored 13 more points that Sheppard last year… and Staubitz equaled the 6 points, but in nearly half as many games. So claiming that they ‘almost matched Sheppard’s production this year’ might be a little insulting to Nystrom and Staubitz. ;-)
Great analysis. I like the Cullen signing. The Wild had to give him a number, as they didn’t want to miss out on both Cullen and Lombardi. I like Cullen better as a center between Gui and Havlat than I would Lombardi. I like the 4th line pick ups… I like that commitment to roll 4 lines.
I really like the fact that Fletcher has definitely deepened the Wild’s pool of prospects, and good prospects at that.
I think he was referring to Boogey and Scott almost matching Shep. Not sure, JS can clarify, but that’s how I read it.
Hockey Wilderness
Assistant Editor:SBN Minnesota
Rule #17: You may not impersonate representatives of Hockey Wilderness and handout NHL themed wrist bands.
Yup, I was refering to Boogey and Scott
JS, Champion of the first ever Hockey Wilderness Playoff Bracket Challenge! WHOOOOOOOO!
twitter: BubbleWild48
Exactly, I see Cullen as the total package.
And yes, overpaying beats not signing anyone.
JS, Champion of the first ever Hockey Wilderness Playoff Bracket Challenge! WHOOOOOOOO!
twitter: BubbleWild48
Overpaying by little I might add.
Cullen got about 750K raise from his previous contract, which is reasonable.
JS, Champion of the first ever Hockey Wilderness Playoff Bracket Challenge! WHOOOOOOOO!
twitter: BubbleWild48
yea, but he’s also a a year older. maybe he’ll come into his prime at 33? haha
by ADN on Jul 8, 2010 9:05 PM CDT up reply actions
Well, if you look at his stats, the only real reasons he never cracked 50...
Games played and unworthy linemates. You can be sure that playing along side BTE and Havlat will do wonders to his point total.
Of course you can’t always look at the points to find one’s worth. We all know Mikko Koivu’s one of the most underrated two-way players in the league, but having mediocre linemates reduces his point output.
And yes, some are late bloomers. Look at Saku Koivu: His most productive season came three seasons ago at age 32. For Daniel Alfredsson, it was 5 seasons ago, also at age 32 (of course this is different as he didn’t always have Heatley and Spezza at his side). But you see what I mean? Some players play their best hockey near the end of their careers.
Cullen WILL post career numbers this year (if he doesn’t miss to many games.)
JS, Champion of the first ever Hockey Wilderness Playoff Bracket Challenge! WHOOOOOOOO!
twitter: BubbleWild48
Well, if Brodziak could be relatively productove offensively when in between Lats and Havlat then I can imagine Cullen could hit 60.
Good career move for Cullen as well, and there’s a good possibility he’ll finish his career with the Wild.
Let's hope so! I think it would be good for him and the fans to have him stay for the rest of his career
JS, Champion of the first ever Hockey Wilderness Playoff Bracket Challenge! WHOOOOOOOO!
twitter: BubbleWild48
Thanks JS! Good Stuff Here :)
I agree that this influx of new prospects most likely spells a trade in the near future, but I just pray that one of the prospects traded is not Matt Hackett. That kid is going to be really good. To put up the numbers he did on a mediocre Plymouth team is a good indicator on how he should perform in the future, once he actually gets some defense and doesn’t have to rely on Tyler Seguin to keep the puck in the other zone.
Don't lose hope! Sykora's case was a very rare misstep.
He didn’t handle leaving Crosby and Malkin too well I reckon
JS, Champion of the first ever Hockey Wilderness Playoff Bracket Challenge! WHOOOOOOOO!
twitter: BubbleWild48
What do you guys think of Semin?
Extremely talented, he gets injured often, gets pushed around a lot and greedy.
Perfect replacement for Gaborik and on Koviu’s line they could put on some great numbers.
Semin makes $6 million this year, and is a UFA after this season. Would take ample assets to pry him away. The question becomes, can they afford him, and can they afford to give up what it would take to get him?
Hockey Wilderness
Assistant Editor:SBN Minnesota
Rule #17: You may not impersonate representatives of Hockey Wilderness and handout NHL themed wrist bands.
Honestly, I would pass
He isn’t a perfect replacement for Gaborik, he IS Gaborik. Sure he’s an exciting player, which we sorely need, but there’s a difference between being talented and being a good hockey player.
Not saying he’s not a good hockey player, he just looks like he doesn’t care at times and is rather one-dimensional. Also very expensive to boot. Of course if we do acquire him, I’ll be doing backflips, but personally, I believe we could do smarter moves than that, because as Bryan said, it would take a lot, perhaps too much, to get him.
JS, Champion of the first ever Hockey Wilderness Playoff Bracket Challenge! WHOOOOOOOO!
twitter: BubbleWild48
Maybe I just don't like Semin all that much because...
Of his failure to show up against the damn Habs in the playoffs… the little bitch!
JS, Champion of the first ever Hockey Wilderness Playoff Bracket Challenge! WHOOOOOOOO!
twitter: BubbleWild48
That’s true, but If I remember correctly I believe he did pretty well in the playoffs the year before.
Oh for sure, when he’s healthy, his goal-scoring prowess can rival that of Ovechkin’s, but there’s a reason he doesn’t fit in the Caps plans. I think it’s the intangibles he lacks. Make no mistake, he would look damn good in Wild colors, but I’m thinking the Wild’s efforts should be concentrated elsewhere.
I think Jeff Carter would be a good choice simply because the ball would be in CF’s court because of the impending cap troubles in Philly, meaning maybe we could have him for less. Of course if it’s Gagne they’re trading, I’m not too sure it would be the best idea to try and nab him.
JS, Champion of the first ever Hockey Wilderness Playoff Bracket Challenge! WHOOOOOOOO!
twitter: BubbleWild48
Carter would be great and can play wing well if needed. I just wish he used his size more, but would be thrilled if we could get him.
I actually think Gagne would be a great fit also and much easier to aquire then Carter. He is a fantastic 2 way player and can score goals. He reminds me of a scoring Havlat. Injuries are a concern though (just like Havlat) plus he has a NTC.
Agreed with what both you guys are saying, but I think with the Caps cap trouble and lack of defense they would be willing to move him. I don’t think Semin fits with the Caps long term plans otherwise they would have signed him long term. He isn’t the greatest fit here but I think he could get the job done and if it doesn’t work out we could just trade his rights at the end of the year. Maybe something involving PMB and a defender would interest them.
Our potential to make move rely almost entirely on whether or not PMB returns to form soon.
JS, Champion of the first ever Hockey Wilderness Playoff Bracket Challenge! WHOOOOOOOO!
twitter: BubbleWild48
I would pass as well because the value of prospects in the Wild organization are at an all time high. We have the luxury of a relatively deep defensive pool of defensive prospects, but I’d rather not see anyone go right now. No need to sacrifice the future to make a short term gain with this team.
This
Actually, we could allow ourselves to trade our prospect D, but only if the price is right. It would be better to keep them, but if we can answer our pressing needs, get ’er done.
JS, Champion of the first ever Hockey Wilderness Playoff Bracket Challenge! WHOOOOOOOO!
twitter: BubbleWild48
I would start seeing if anyone would bite with Noreau. He had a great year in the AHL and could draw some interest. And then there’s Harding… the goalie market has been deep for a couple years, so I don’t think the Wild will get too much for him if a deal gets done.
I think Fletch has done an excellent job, and I trust that he’ll make the right decisions.

by 
















