FanPost

Minnesota Wild: How the Off-Season player moves match up

Last Season, the Minnesota Wild have made it more interesting when they made the 2012- 2013 playoffs since the 2007- 2008 season. After five years of missing the playoffs, you've got to get in there and taste it and see what it's like and experience those types of games. Even though the Wild got eliminated by the eventual cup winners Chicago Blackhawks, the Wild have moved a step forward. But the Wild made several moves in the Off-season in the subtraction of Cal Clutterbuck, Pierre- Marc Bouchard, Justin Falk, Devin Setoguchi, Tom Gilbert, and Matt Cullen. The additions are Nino Niederreiter, Matt Cooke, and Keith Ballard. We'll see how they match up to really see if the off-season moves benefited or obstructed the Wild.

Matt Cullen vs Mikael Granlund

Role: Second-line Center

Out: Cullen

Size: 6 foot 1, 200 pounds

Strengths: Experience, responsible on both ends, special teams

Weakness: Age (37)

In: Mikael Granlund

Strengths: Skill, Creative in offensive zone, Great play maker.

Weaknesses: Size, inexperience, translating to NHL play.

Advantage:
Cullen is clearly the better player. Granlund, the Wild's first-round draft pick in 2010, hasn't put it all together yet. The spot was projected to be his a year ago, but he struggled in the NHL. Granlund is clearly entering his sophomore season, and he can put his disappointing rookie season behind him. The Wild needs Granlund to live up to his potential. He is a great passer with excellent hockey sense and fits nicely as a 2nd- line center that the Wild most desperately needs since the departure of Cullen. If Granlund can't take the No. 2 center role, the Wild likely will have to move proven Charlie Coyle from the wing to center as an option. Or Wild's 2009 seventh- round draft pick Erik Haula, that's fighting for a spot, is another candidate for 2nd- line center.

Devin Setoguchi vs Jason Zucker

Role: Second-line Scorer

Out: Setoguchi

Size: 6 feet, 205 pounds.

Strengths: Goal scoring, creating chances in offensive zone

Weaknesses: Inconsistency, two-way game

In: Jason Zucker

Size: 5 foot 11, 186 pounds

Strengths: Goal scoring, speed, creating chances in offensive zone, two- way play.

Weaknesses: Inconsistency

Advantage: It came very close but Setoguchi gets the nod here with the experience. These players are very similar, Zucker is young and could prove to be the scorer the Wild wants. But Setoguchi is already a proven player. If Zucker plays well this year, he can put up a season comparable to Setoguchi, maybe even more with his gritty game. Zucker is young and has the chance to put all his skills together. But for 2013-14, Setoguchi would have been the better choice.

Cal Clutterbuck vs Matt Cooke

Role: 3rd- line checking winger

Out: Clutterbuck

Size: 5 foot 11, 213 pounds

Strengths: Physical game, agitator

Weakness: Goal-scoring inconsistency

In: Matt Cooke

Size: 5 foot 11, 205

Strengths: Physical game, experience, goal scoring

Weakness: Reputation as a dirty player

Advantage: They're similar, but Cooke is the better player, and he has shown that during his longer career. He's more of a proven scorer and agitator than Clutterbuck, though both play physical and are good on the penalty kill, and is a better two-way player.

Pierre- Marc Bouchard vs Nino Niederreiter

Role: 3rd-line Winger

Out: Bouchard

Size: 5 foot 11, 171 pounds

Strengths: Power play, playmaking ability

Weaknesses: Injuries, inconsistency, physical play

In: Niederreiter

Size: 6 foot 2, 208 pounds

Strengths: Size, shot, skill, scoring

Weakness: Translating to NHL Play

Advantage: Bouchard gets the nod here, with the experience, and solely on the fact that he's a proven commodity. He said he's healthy, and he'll likely put up improved numbers with the Islanders. Niederreiter has the potential to be a scoring top-six forward, but until he puts it all together, Bouchard gets the advantage.

Tom Gilbert vs Marco Scandella

Role: 2nd-line defensive pairing

Out: Gilbert

Size: 6 foot 2, 204 pounds

Strengths: Experience

Weakness: Inconsistency

In: Scandella

Size: 6 foot 3, 210 pounds

Strengths: Physical play, size, two-way game

Weakness: Inexperience

Advantage: This one is close, but Scandella slightly has the upper hand. He didn't play well last season, but he earned his contract by playing well in the first-round playoff series against the Chicago Blackhawks. Gilbert played well in his first season with the Wild but struggled in 2013, and the Wild used a compliance buyout to get rid of him.

Justin Falk vs Keith Ballard

Role: Third-line defensive pairing

Size: 6 foot 5, 215 pounds

Strengths: Size, physical game

Weaknesses: Offense, ability to move the puck, giving up turnovers in defensive zone

In: Ballard

Size: 5 foot 11, 208 pounds

Strengths: Skating, two-way player, passing, physical game

Weaknesses: Inconsistency, building on early career success

Advantage: I gave Ballard the nod here. Falk was a healthy scratch at times, but provided physical play to the blue- line, but that's all he could do. Ballard is a talented two-way player, but after two disappointing seasons with the Vancouver Canucks due to him not seeing the fair playing time that he deserves, he's in need of a change of scenery. If his game returns in his years of playing in Phoenix and Florida, the Wild will have gotten a bargain. If not, they'll find themselves yearning for Falk.

So Wild fans, is the Minnesota Wild gonna have a better season, or a down season?

The opinions posted here are not those of Hockey Wilderness

X
Log In Sign Up

forgot?
Log In Sign Up

Forgot password?

We'll email you a reset link.

If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

Forgot password?

Try another email?

Almost done,

By becoming a registered user, you are also agreeing to our Terms and confirming that you have read our Privacy Policy.

Join Hockey Wilderness

You must be a member of Hockey Wilderness to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Hockey Wilderness. You should read them.

Join Hockey Wilderness

You must be a member of Hockey Wilderness to participate.

We have our own Community Guidelines at Hockey Wilderness. You should read them.

Spinner.vc97ec6e

Authenticating

Great!

Choose an available username to complete sign up.

In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.

tracking_pixel_9355_tracker