clock menu more-arrow no yes mobile

Filed under:

Is Jonas Brodin Starting To Emerge From His Sophomore Slump?

Jonas Brodin's struggles this year after being so dominant in his rookie season are old news at this point. But is he starting to turn it around and get back to his best?

Charles LeClaire-USA TODAY Sport

When Brodin broke into the NHL last year as a 19 year old, he performed at a level that even the most optimistic fan would never have thought possible. He was solid as a rock on the top pairing alongside Ryan Suter and his elite skating, great positional sense and nerves of steel were on show game after game. After those 45 excellent regular season games (and 5 not so great playoff games) he came into this season under the weight of huge expectations. Fans wanted to see him continue to transform into an elite defenceman. Unfortunately, things didn't quite go to plan...

The young Swede struggled to find his feet early in the season. He seemed to be under more pressure when the puck was on his stick and often made bad decisions as a result. He wasn't playing with the same calm dominance that he had enjoyed the previous season and it resulted in him being demoted from the top pairing numerous times during games as Mike Yeo tried to take him out of the firing line. Jared Spurgeon's injury has resulted in Brodin returning to his usual spot on the top pairing beside Suter.

It's not that big of a deal for a young player to struggle in their second season (the term "sophomore slump" exists for a reason) but I feel that it's important to look a bit closer at Brodin's performance now that his 45-game sample of great play from last year has been out-weighed by a 48 game sample of not-great play this season. Which sample is the truest indicator of his potential, and which way is his performance trending this year after a rough start?

Let's try to find some answers in the numbers. For the following analysis, I've set the criteria as "Wild defencemen who have payed 25% of the season so far", which leaves 8 players for this year's numbers, and 7 for last year.

-Firstly, here are his basic splits between last season and this season:



51.8% (1st)


47.4% (7th)

+3.2% (1st)

CF% rel

-4.2% (7th)

29.1% (2nd)

TotTm% QoC

29.2% (2nd)

30.35 (1st)

TotTm% QoT

31.0% (1st)

30.6% (5th)

O-Zone Start%

34.8% (3rd)

34.0% (2nd)

D-Zone Start%

29.8% (6th)

  • His possession numbers have taken a huge leap backwards. His CF% (percentage of shot attempts the Wild have while he is on the ice at 5v5) has gone from being the best of the entire D-corps, to the 2nd worst, with only Nate Prosser having poorer numbers.
  • His TotTm% QoC (which relates to the toughness of competition he faces at 5v5) is pretty much the same this year, as is his TotTm% QoT (quality of teammates).
  • His zone-starts have become easier this year compared to last year. In 2012/12 he started around 5% more in the defensive zone, and around 5% less in the offensive zone.
  • So, in theory, with pretty much the same level of competition and teammates and easier zone starts Brodin's possession numbers should be better....but they're not, they're much worse.
  • What we have been seeing with our eyes in regard to Brodin's defensive play seems to show up in the numbers.

A positive aspect of his play this year has been his goalscoring, which has done a lot to mask some of his defensive deficiencies. Let's take a closer look at his scoring rates, focusing on his overall and even-strength Goals per 60 minutes, Points per 60 minutes and Primary Points (Goals+1st Assists) per 60 minutes. I have also included his Shots per 60 minutes, Shot Attempts (Corsi) per 60 minutes and his Shooting Percentage.

-Here are his scoring numbers, with the same criteria as the previous table:



0.11 (4th)


0.36 (2nd)

0.63 (5th)


0.76 (6th)

0.29 (4th)


0.36 (6th)

0.07 (3rd)

EV G/60

0.24 (2nd)

0.62 (4th)

EV P/60

0.49 (6th)

0.21 (3rd)

EV P1/60

0.24 (6th)

2.9 (4th)


2.2 (8th)

6.2 (6th)


5.6 (7th)

3.9% (4th)


15.9% (1st)

  • His overall scoring has improved since last year yet he ranks lower, which is probably due to the Wild's defencemen scoring a lot more as a whole.
  • He's scoring points at a slower rate than last season at even-strength, though he is scoring more primary points.
  • He had a higher rate of shots and shot attempts last year, which is a testament to how much more time he spent in the offensive zone in his rookie campaign as opposed to this season.
  • His unsustainability high shooting percentage is padding his offensive numbers a bit. There's no way he will continue to score on nearly 16% of the shots he takes. He didn't have nearly as much shooting luck last season.

So we've established that Brodin's overall performance has been disappointing compared to last year so now let's see if his performance this year is trending in the right direction.

-Below I have shown his game-by-game CF% this season along with a linear trend line (apologies for the poor quality, Y-Axis is 0-100% in 10% intervals, X-Axis is games 1-48):


  • This is really positive. While the Wild's team level possession numbers have been sharply declining since the start of the year, Brodin's are gradually trending upwards.

-Here is the same type of graph, only this time with Brodin's CF% relative to his teammates:


  • As you can see, this is very much trending in the right direction, while the team as a whole has been getting worse, Brodin has steadily been improving.

With Spurgeon out hurt, Brodin couldn't have picked a better time to start finding his game again. Hopefully, once Spurge is back in the fold, Brodin continues to trend in the right direction for the rest of the season. I think last season was a glimpse at his true potential and he isn't far from returning to that level of play, he just needs to regain his confidence.

Now that he is finding some form, one would think that when Koivu, Parise and Spurgeon (the team's two best puck possession forwards and best puck possession defenceman) return to the team, it will make things even easier for him. If he's able to play well while the Wild have been extremely depleted, he should be able to play even better when the team is fully healthy, now that he is looking a bit more like his old self.

I'll be keeping a close eye on Brodin for the rest of the season to see if he can show everyone why his nickname is "Kidstrom" and not "Kidlicky".

Follow me on Twitter for more analysis and opinion.